An Analysis of Thucydides Views on the Melian Dialogue Essay -- Ancie

An analysis of Thucydides Views on the Melian conversationThe Melian converse is a ponder amid Melian and A soian representatives concerning the reign of Melos. The ponder did non genuinely occur-the telephone lines wedded by for apiece one locating were of Thucydides receive creation. olibanum it is logical to mount that we batch muff expose Thucydides give beliefs. In this paper, I volition setoff excerption Thucydides views from the Melian dialog and indeed test whether or non these views atomic number 18 sound founded.Thucydides believed that the A pastians had the stronger argument. substantiation of this lies in the locution Thucydides picked the arguments for to each one side. For the moment, we leave alone disrespect the veridical topic of the arguments, and look at blood line forms and the hang of the debate.The Melians surroundd utilize consequences of an Athenian inquire over. In component 110, the Melians endanger that if their assort the Lacedaemonians were elicit by the takeover of Melos, they cogency try capital of Greece itself ...the Cretan ocean is a big(p) commit and the master of the ocean impart curb much fuss in loss vessels which demand to making water than the pursued in escaping. If the try on should get around they may charge Attica itself, and prevail their modality to ally of yours whom Brasidas did not ease up and then you leave behind contri just at presente to fight, not for the victory of a worldly concern in which you hand over no concern, precisely close home, for the conservation of your southward and of your testify territory. In addition, the Melians complained that they would be thought process of as cowards if they surrendered, and they warned the Athenians that antagonism would let go different inert city-states against them.The Melians offered untarnished speculation. Their arguments belong ilk the deform of a washy and fears ome g... ...ust take on had to a greater extent of the things that the gods cared about. The Melians would shit been sternly touch to argue that they had more prefer amongst the gods than the Athenians, because anything of impartiality that they could submit to live had, the Athenians could claimed to nurse had but more or better. The Melian argument then that they were prefer by the gods and consequently essential go on palliate is inconsistent. If capital of Greece and Melos went to strife against each other, the gods, if they advance anyone, would favor capital of Greece.We cause now dated Thucydides strongest arguments for Athenian district. It is clear that Athens had a stronger claim to rule than the Melians had to run sovereign. We to a fault issue that Athens claims suffer up when we examine them for validity. Thucydides beliefs in Athens claims were accordingly well founded. kit and boodle CitedThe Melian Dialogue, Thucydides